Skip to content
Home » Kid & Baby » Best Baby Crib mattresses in 2023

Best Baby Crib mattresses in 2023

    Baby Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

    Your baby is precious. We understand that you want to give your new child the best of everything. Making them rest or sleep safely and soundly is what every parent is looking for. For that reason, you should consider getting one of the top 10 best baby crib mattresses in 2023. Even if there are a lot of products available on the market and makes your experience look overwhelming and confusing, no worries. We understand the dilemma.

    That is the reason why we have created a list of best baby crib mattress reviews in 2023 for you to take a look at. Minimizing to the top 10 best, any product you are going to get is always of great quality.  

    Table of Contents

    List of  Top 10 Best Baby Crib Mattresses in 2023

    10. Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

    Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

      Buy on

    Providing your baby with all the comfort you can is important. That is why this mattress is designed with 80 coils that provide all the support and comfort your baby requires. Moreover, the polyurethane foam fabric is anti-bacterial, waterproof, and closed stitched to make sure mold, mildew, and odor do not contaminate the interior foam.

    It is phthalate and lead-free and reversible. You can choose between a white and brown exterior. All you need to clean it in warm water with a little soap and a cloth. That’s it, simple and easy. For your information, the mattress measures 51.5 x 27.5 x 5 inches.

    What We Like: 

    • Thanks to its 80 coils construction, it offers support and comfort to your little ones.
    • Together with the assistance from polyurethane foam, it is a waterproof crib mattress that goes against bacteria, mildew, and odors.
    • This mattress is very lightweight.

    What We Don’t Like:

    • It requires a bit of effort to maintain as it needs to be washed with warm water with a little soap and clothes.

    9. Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

    Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

      Buy on

    When you buy this product for your baby, make sure you do not use it for the first 72 hours. This is because it will need to expand to its full size before you get the best results. Furthermore, This crib mattress meets all federal safety requirements and is covered by a 6-year limited warranty.

    Other features include a water-resistant inner lining, anti-static and anti-microbial treatment. Plus, it is lead and phthalate-free. The removable mattress cover is easy to clean. The mattress measures 52 x 27.6 x 5 inches.

    What We Like: 

    • The product is made from materials that are water-resistant, odorless, anti-static, and anti-microbial.
    • It is totally free from from phthalate and other chemical substances making it safe for babies.
    • Plus, the mattress also comes with its cover that can be washed by either hand or machine.

    What We Don’t Like:

    • Users need to leave it up to 72 hours before their first use for it to fully expand.

    8. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

    Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

      Buy on

    You know that when it comes to white color mattress it represents pureness and simplicity for the baby. This is one of the best crib mattress reviews that you should not miss out on. Being a hypoallergenic crib mattress, it has a 50-pound weight capacity. However, it is water-resistant. Measuring 52.5 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches, the mattress sports an all vinyl cover with a thermos packed interior.

    No harmful chemicals were used to meet the federal fire requirements. What is more, the core of the mattress is made of polyester. Besides, it is very lightweight too. But, the only drawback of this mattress is that it might only fit well to the standard baby crib only.

    What We Like: 

    • It is made of hypoallergenic materials that are safe for babies with any skin types.
    • Holding up to 50 pounds of weight, it will never change its shapes and always flatten back to its original shade and size.
    • It also comes with a vinyl cover accompanied by a thermos interior too.

    What We Don’t Like:

    • Most buyers said the mattress is a bit too firm.

    7. Dream On Me 3″ Playard Mattress

    Dream On Me 3" Playard Mattress

      Buy on

    Made from 10% vinyl and 90% foam this anti-bacteria mattress has waterproof stitching. This stitching will protect the interior foam from mildew, mold, and odor. The dimensions, 37.5″ x 25.5″ x 3″, fit a smaller baby, weighing up to 45 pounds.

    Manufactured in America, this mattress meets all American fire standards for utmost safety. Phthalate and lead-free, this mattress is supported by a limited 10-year warranty. Plus, the wire border keeps the mattress from sagging and the ventilation system keeps the mattress fresh.

    What We Like: 

    • The mattress is constructed with a blend of vinyl and foam.
    • It is highly anti-bacterial, and waterproof.
    • The stitching is done very well that it will not get worn or torn apart at all.
    • It is able to handle up to 45 pounds of weight.
    • Being a phthalate and lead-free product, it is very safe with children.
    • It is also backed by a 10-year warranty.

    What We Don’t Like:

    • The product might fit with some cribs only. Measurement beforehand is required.

    6. Milliard Memory Foam Crib Mattress

    Milliard Memory Foam Crib Mattress

      Buy on

    Bring a touch of the orient to your child’s life. This bamboo covered memory foam/regular foam combination brings lots of support and comfort to your child. The bamboo cover is soft and machine washable. More to that, the hypoallergenic interior foam protects against allergens, mold, bacteria, and dust mites.

    In addition, the ventilation provides great air-flow to keep your baby cool when it sleeps. Together with the 27.5″x52″x5.5″ dimensions, this product should fit most standard size cribs. Interestingly, this is a safe, non-toxic product as no chemicals were used in its construction. All fire safety standards are met as well.

    What We Like: 

    • It goes well with any kind of standards baby cribs.
    • Being made of hypoallergenic materials, it is totally fine for baby skin.
    • This baby crib mattress also resists to allergens, mold, bacteria, and dust mites.
    • It is breathable and never keep your baby sweat.

    What We Don’t Like:

    • It is a little bit heavy.

    5. Milliard Crib Mattress

    Milliard Crib Mattress, Dual Comfort System

      Buy on

    This mattress does double duty. It has a firm side for young babies and when you flip it, there is a softer side for toddlers. What is more, the interior is made of regular foam for comfort and memory foam for support. Not to mention, its 100% cotton cover is waterproof and has breathability features. For this reason, you can wash it with ease.

    On top of this, the 52 x 27½ x 5.5-inch dimensions will fit most standard crib sizes. You can purchase this worry-free as the mattress meets all safety requirements. Plus, the mattress is BPA, chemical, lead, etc., free.

    What We Like: 

    • It is a product that is free from BPA, chemical, lead materials.
    • With this mattress, users can use both sizes: firm and soft sizes.
    • It serves both little babies and toddlers.
    • The product is lightweight & the cover is waterproof.

    What We Don’t Like:

    • It requires high maintenance.

    4. My First Crib Mattress

    My First Crib Mattress

      Buy on

    Your baby will not wake up when it moves on this memory foam mattress. It is designed to make no noise when your child moves as it sleeps. The 51.6 x 5 x 27.2-inch mattress is made of flexible polyurethane foam, is hypoallergenic and resists molds, mites, mildew, and anti-microbial. The removable, waterproof cover is both soft and washable.

    Plus, its phthalate and lead-free construction meet all fire and safety standards. When you purchase a mattress for your baby. Make sure it is firm. Soft mattresses bring their own dangers to babies.

    What We Like: 

    • The mattress is a product of noiseless.
    • It is created from flexible polyurethane foam which will offer a great contour to accommodate your baby’s body.
    • This one has the ability to resist molds, mites, mildew, and microbes.
    • It goes well with most cribs including those of newborn and toddlers.

    What We Don’t Like:

    • Nothing to dislike.

    3. Official Amazon Exclusive NapYou Dual Comfort Crib Mattress

    Crib mattress

      Buy on

    NapYou is highly recommended by a lot of parents due to its good features and comfort. With this product, it goes on as your child grows because it has a dual comfort design making it suitable for both baby and toddler. When you have a newborn baby, you can use a firmer size. Once your child grows into a toddler, simply flip to another size for a softer effect.

    Moreover, it is constructed from a supportive foam which will be able to withstand the weight of your baby very well. Thereby, leaving out no discomforts at all for the neck and back areas. Besides, this crib mattress does come with a cover that is waterproof. All of this thanks to the combination of waterproof elements and organic cotton.

    What We Like:

    • It offers a dual comfort in which you can flip size and use for both baby and toddler.
    • Constructed using a supportive foam, it offers ultimate support to your baby and toddlers’ necks and backs.
    • The cover is highly waterproof, odorless, and easy to wash.

    What We Don’t Like:

    • Its price tag is high.

    2. Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

    Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

      Buy on

    This Sealy crib mattress for babies is the next choice you can look at. Be environmentally friendly by using this soybean filled baby crib mattress. Not only do you help farmers, but you provide your baby with a firm mattress. Besides, the lock stitching seals the reinforced waterproof cover. Additionally, it is not only stain-resistant, but liquids also do not get to the interior foam.

    For your information, the 51.6 x 27.2 x 5-inch size will allow this mattress to be inserted in most standard cribs. Your baby and toddler will have a firm comfortable mattress to sleep on each night. Also, a limited lifetime warranty protects this investment.

    What We Like: 

    • It fits perfectly with most standard cribs.
    • This baby crib mattress is highly resistant to liquid, stains, odor, and bacterias.
    • It is made from environmentally friendly materials that are totally organic.

    What We Don’t Like:

    • Do not get it if your baby is allergic to soybean.

    1. Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress

    Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress-Baby Crib mattresses

      Buy on

    Available in 4 color options, users can choose between white, pink, moonlight grey, and sky blue. What is more, this 100% breathable mattress protects against any suffocation issues. Furthermore, the uniquely designed crib mattress contains no foam, springs, latex, or allergens. As a result of this, it is completely washable as well.

    You can be environmentally friendly also when you make use of it. Once you are finished using it, you can simply recycle it. The 52 x 28 x 5.5-inch mattress is made from 90% air and 10% polymer. Therefore, this means you get a chemical-free, odor-free, allergen-free mattress for your baby. Lastly, it is also Greenguard certified.

    What We Like: 

    • There are 4 colors provided: white, pink, moonlight, grey, and sky blue.
    • The mattress is easy to wash & it is totally breathable which will never keep your baby sweaty at all.
    • It is easy to recycle once you no longer need it.
    • Being a Greenguard certified product, it is highly safe to use.
    • It also comes with a cover that can be washed by either hands or machines.

    What We Don’t Like:

    • The price might be the only concern.

    Buying Guide to Choosing Baby Crib Mattresses

    Newborn babies are very sensitive creatures to anything. That might be the reason why most parents invest a lot of time and money to look for the best of the best products for them. Getting high-quality baby crib mattresses should be the first thing every parent-to-be needs to prepare. Whether you are a new parent or an experienced parent, getting one product might require you to seek help and consultation. Below is a list of some helpful buying guides that you can follow to get worthy products out of all on the market these days.


    First of all, we want you to consider size. Most commonly in the USA, people often choose any baby crib mattresses that can fit into standard cribs. That means it is supposed to be roughly 27 1/4 inches x 51 5/8 inches. That is for the size. Moreover, you should think about its thickness as well. The mattress should be roughly 3 to 5 inches thick. Meanwhile, the maximized thickness is 6 inches, and no thicker than this. If you have already bought a standard-sized baby crib, you can rely on these measurements. Still, make sure to measure it in advance before ordering.

    Used Materials

    As already stated above, newborn babies are very sensitive to anything around them. And when you look for a mattress, it is supposed to be the thing that they, most of the time, stay with. That means both day and night time. For this reason, you should look for any products that are made totally free from harmful elements. The things that should be excluded are BPA, lead, chemical, allergens, and more.

    Dual-Comfort Feature

    This factor is actually optional. However, if you can get one it will be better. For any baby crib mattresses that come with this Dual-Comfort Features allows you to continue using it from when your baby is newborn up to when they grow into a toddler. There are both sizes of the mattress that you can use. One is firm, and another is softer. The firm one serves for a newborn baby while the softer one is designed to support toddlers.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Q1: How do I choose baby crib mattresses?

    A: Firstly, you should focus on size. That is to say, choose the right size that can fit perfectly into the baby crib. Secondly, check whether or not the used materials are actually safe for your newborn baby. Please keep in mind that newborn babies are ways more sensitive than we think. Getting an environmentally-friendly or organic product ensures the safety and soundness of your beloved child.

    Q2: What kind of mattress is best for newborns?

    A: According to a lot of research, double-sided mattresses are highly recommended for newborn babies. However, parents can use other things include high-density foam mattresses and any mattresses that are made of coils.

    Q3: How much should I spend on a crib mattress?

    A: Generally, a baby crib mattress costs between 90 USD up to 300 USD. The more expensive the product, the better it is.

    Q4: Why are baby mattresses so hard?

    A: The manufacturer makes the mattress so hard for the babies is because once the baby becomes a lot more active, they require firm surface to support them and to give them resistance. This way, it enables them to push, turn, as well as stand up tall on the mattress.

    Some final words

    Providing one of the top 10 best baby crib mattresses in 2023 is just one step in the right direction. Your baby gets protected, has a comfortable sleep and you can use them as your family grows. But no matter which baby crib mattress you choose, it will be best if you are satisfied with it. All we are doing is pointing you in the right direction, so you can get that perfect mattress for your precious child. In choosing a top 10 best baby crib mattress in 2023 you are getting the best of the best.

    Hopefully, with this information, your choice has gotten easier. One thing is for sure, the quality and care for your baby is there in these top 10 mattresses.

    Leave a Reply